PlanetCatfish.com

i have recantly moved to Chandler AZ and i had to leave my 40 gallon tank(we have people tanking good care of the fish) and i have in it a two sun catfish and a four line pim i am getting a from 60 gallon tank and i was wondering which catfish would be best in my tank (i would like somthing from hemibagrus and i am not a very big pleco fan but dosnt mean i hate plecos but its up to u )

That's a tough one. Standard 55 gal has a footprint of only 4'x1', normally cannot be used (again, humanely) to house a longer than 6" fish. 75 can be still 1' or 1.5' wide. Using the tank footprint info and the rule of thumb 4xL by 2xL by ~2xL, you can browse through the Hemibagrus genus in Cat-eLog and see if there are any smaller ones that can fit the bill.

i have always used for every inch of fish u should have 1 gallon of tank plus 10 gallons of swmming room

p.s i edit my first post and i was wonder if i could keep a id shark with them but keeping it under 18 inchies

ID sharks are constant swimmers, and a nervous, easily spooked fish and will require a tank bigger then the recommended 4L x 2L minimum usually quoted. These are not a suitable fish for captivity except for tropical ponds or gigantic aquaria

so like a 3000 gallon tank and i have hered that they only grow to the size of there tank like goldfish is this true?

Growing to the size of the tank, aka stunting, does not always work - in other words it may or may not work... but, regardless... in either case it involves keeping an animal in such tight quarters that are considered by most experts, high-level hobbyists, and aficionados utterly inhumane. It would not be unlike keeping a Mastino neapolitano in a bathroom hoping it stays a poodle size or a Clydesdale in a bedroom hoping it stays a pony size because neither one can move much.

However, there are plenty of followers of the opposing school of thought, typically youngsters who cannot afford an appropriate tank but still wanna keep a large fish... so they invent their own school of thought to justify themselves in their eyes. I honestly do not know if there exist serious experts, ichthyologists, etc. who support this point of view. There maybe are... I just have not come across one yet.

An adult captive IDS of modest proportions, say 2' long, would at a minimum need a 6xL by 3xL by 2xL tank, which is 12'x6'x3'-4' which is roughly 7000 liters or 2000 US gal. On the upside, one can easily have a stunning school of 10 adult IDSs in such a tank with appropriate bio-filtration and water changes.

Now IDS can reach 3' in captivity and one can choose to go beyond the minimum debatable (?) requirement. That will easily double the tank volume.

if you like the looks and behavior of Pangasius, you could go for

this is a very active cat, but it's not stressed.....it's visible all day, does great in a group of 5 or more, is tough as an old nail and can be kept with a long list of other fish
it also reaches 1 foot max, most of the time 8-9" is already almost grown out

you can keep it in a much smaller tank than needed for the IDS.

if you stick to 40-50G tanks, you could go for the "miniature option
you still have the active shoaling behavior of the IDS, but you can keep 10-15 individuals of -for example- , or


in my opinion THE most beautiful of all the "miniature shark like cats" is

it would make one hell of a stunner in a large 8 foot tank...imagine 12 or so in such a tank

unfortunately it is very rare in the hobby, but it has a lot going for it as a tank beauty

i love clupisoma prateri it looks kinda like a paroon shark and its cool as fudge sickles but will my my sun cats rip to peices because i had the schilbe intermedius but the sun cats ate it and could i keep 1 or 2 of the last cat

for my my fish tank my mom wants some fish that swim around and i want more catfish so i was wondering which of these would go best with my fish tank

pimelodus ornatus

platystomatichthys sturio

sorubim lima

clupisoma prateri

ompok pabda

You're probably not gonna find Clupisoma or true Ompok, but the "Ompok catfish", which if I'm not mistaken is actually something like , is actually a pretty ideal fish if you want a catfish that will swim around. The other fish are not really good choices for a tank as small as a 60 gallon.

but do you have to keep them in shoals and will my sun cats rip it to shreads? like what they do with pinky mice

They do need to be kept in groups. Most of the shark-like catfishes should be kept in groups.

If the sun cats can eat them then they will eat them. However, I've never seen sun cats tear food instead of just swallow it whole, although that is just my experience. If you plan to keep sun cats with fish then you will need a much larger tank, as big sun cats will require space, but any shark-like fish that can keep out of a sun cat's gullet will need even more space for their swimming habits.

they only tare there food if its to big and the funny thing is they learnd to take advantage of working in a group of 3 but asoon as they kill the prey the biggest one smudge chases everyone away and drags his prey into his little HQ

CatfishPownage63 wrote:i have recantly moved to Chandler AZ and i had to leave my 40 gallon tank(we have people tanking good care of the fish) and i have in it a three sun catfish and a four line pim i am getting a from 60 gallon tank and i was wondering which catfish would be best in my tank (i would like somthing from hemibagrus and i am not a very big pleco fan but dosnt mean i hate plecos but its up to u )

I am sorry but I lost track of thought in this thread. Now I am trying to re-read the OP and I am struggling again. Hard read. What does the 40 gal and its inhabitants, which are left behind, has to do with the planned 60 gal?

Would it be too much if the OP could re-phrase the question(s) or define the situation again? Is the 60 gal planned to have sun cats?

Also, what is pinky mice?

Sorry.

Viktor Jarikov wrote:Also, what is pinky mice?

Baby mice that have not yet grown a full coat of hair. At the pet store, one just asks for pinkies.


Also (sorry, couldn't resist): http://lmgtfy.com/?q=pinky+mice

the fish are in the 40 gallon and we are going to ship them once i get a 60 or a 75 gallon and iam tring to chose fish to go with and my mom want fish that swim around and i want more catfish so i have some chose some fish and iam asking u guys which fish would be the with my 2 sun cats and a 4 line pimelodus and the fish that i like are

synodintis granulosa

pimelodus ornatus

platystomatichthys sturio

sorubim lima

cluisoma prateri

Suckermouth wrote: If you plan to keep sun cats with fish then you will need a much larger tank, as big sun cats will require space.

i was told by my local pet store that they reach 18 inches in the wild and they said in an aquairum they would only reach anyware from 8 in. to a foot

CatfishPownage63 wrote: in an aquairum they would only reach anyware from 8 in. to a foot

For a catfish in the 8-12" TL range, I would think you would want at least a 4' long tank. Not sure of the dimensions of the 60gal you mention, but if it is not at least 4' long, I would recommend the 75gal. 125gal is really a much better option if you have the space and funds. 150gal is where the price steps up considerably. Food for thought.

the 60 gallon is 4 feet l by 15 w 20 h

i would get a 150 gallon if i could but i live in a 1,500 square foot apartment and my mom has to have her way and she has a certan spot for my tank and the biggest dementions i can have are 68 in. long by 20 in. wide by 24 in. high

p.s how do u change your avitar?

Thanks much for the recap. If your Mom'd like visible fish and you like catfish, then the obvious solution is to get catfish that don't hide or don't hide much. A school of at least 6-7 Pimelodus pictus comes to mind, or P. ornatus or other smallish Pims, as well as a school of at least 6-7 sun cats, hopefully we are talking . Both are spectacular especially at larger sizes and you need such numbers so they swim around instead of hiding.

Judging from your passion, you will only wanna get bigger and bigger tanks, so may be wise to just get the biggest for the space.

You feed pinky mice to your sun cats and they shred them to pieces? Both points would be a first I've ever encountered but I hope I did not understand you correctly.

May I humbly suggest you consider capitalization, punctuation, and full sentences - it will be easier and quicker for people to help you. Texting is really for 2-3-word cell phone sentences. This forum, unlike the vast majority of others, has little teenagers and lots of seasoned members and experts, who are put off by texting, see, e.g., http://www.planetcatfish.com/forum/view ... 60#p247700
(In no way am I implying I am perfect in my following my own preaching but I try.)

i dont feed them pinky mice on a regular basis but my freind sent me a picture of a pinky mouse and asks ''what should i do with it'' so i said " let the cats feast!!!" and he sent me a video of my biggest sun cat (smudge) eating the pinky mouse,but he didn't tare it. and it took him a while to get it down,but he got it down. and they only rip food up if it too big (smudge once ate an african leaf fish but when i tried to pull the leaf fis out of his mouth he would not let go and if i kept pulling on the leaf fish the leaf fish would get riped in half)

p.s sorry for my terrible grammer its not my best subject obviously. and i'm not to good at spelling ether but i'm only 12 (almost 13)

braking news!!!!
my smallest sun cat (smidge) was injered very badly in a battle of territory and has died from injeries

because my friend just sent me the heart braking text

synodintis granulosa - very expensive, very aggressive, needs hard alkaline wares with lots of rockwork - not a good choice

pimelodus ornatus - not bad but really needs to be in a group in a 4x2 footprint minimum

platystomatichthys sturio - poor choice, skittish , needs peaceful tank mates in big big tank

sorubim lima - needs to be in a group without aggressive tank mates - not a great choice

cluisoma prateri[/quote] - dunno....

so could i keep 3 pimelodus ornatus and how how expensive is synodontis granulosa?

Not sure of US prices - over here they are typically £150 each (Granulosa)

so what currency do you use?

British pounds.

Currently you get 1.25 euros for a pound, and a euro dos something like 1.25 US dollars today (yes, I admit, shockingly low) - thus 150 pounds comes close to 190 US dollars

so a synodontis granulosa is like 200 dollars ...holy hony butt munches of oats